Harry Potter women vs Twilight women
Jul 19, 2012 6:24:14 GMT -8
Post by Deleted on Jul 19, 2012 6:24:14 GMT -8
Right so im a massive Harry Potter fan and i hate how Twilight is often compared to it. In my view they don't even come close to being similar. The main difference i see between the two is the women:
In Twilight: Edward leaves Bella for her own "protection", she breaks down in the middle of a forest and goes practically catatonic for months on end sending pathetic emails to a deavtivated account.
In Harry Potter: Harry breaks up with Ginny for her protection, she gets upset but then goes back to Hogwarts, re forms the DA, fights against Snapes regime and tries to steal back the sword of Gryffindorr. Ron leaves Hermione, she cries herself to sleep most nights but doesn't want to show weakness infront of Harry and stays with him trying to find the hourcruxes that will defeat the greatest dark wizard of all time. And even when he returnes she doesn't go runnig into his arms she stays angry at him for weeks.
Twilight: Bella will do anything to be with Edward including rising herlife,giving up her family and losing her mortality.
Harry Potter: Hermione clearly likes Ron and she could change to be more like Lavender and be all girly and stupid so that he wil notice her, but she doesn't. She stays true to who she is, she knows that if Ron doesn't like her for who she is then he's not worth the effort. Instead she waits for him to be emotionally ready and for him to realise that he loves her too. It's the same with Luna she does't compromise on who she is, she knows people think she's "odd" but her desire for friendship doesn't mean she's going to change who she is. She knows that real friends will love her exactly the way she is.
In Twilight: Edward leaves Bella for her own "protection", she breaks down in the middle of a forest and goes practically catatonic for months on end sending pathetic emails to a deavtivated account.
In Harry Potter: Harry breaks up with Ginny for her protection, she gets upset but then goes back to Hogwarts, re forms the DA, fights against Snapes regime and tries to steal back the sword of Gryffindorr. Ron leaves Hermione, she cries herself to sleep most nights but doesn't want to show weakness infront of Harry and stays with him trying to find the hourcruxes that will defeat the greatest dark wizard of all time. And even when he returnes she doesn't go runnig into his arms she stays angry at him for weeks.
Twilight: Bella will do anything to be with Edward including rising herlife,giving up her family and losing her mortality.
Harry Potter: Hermione clearly likes Ron and she could change to be more like Lavender and be all girly and stupid so that he wil notice her, but she doesn't. She stays true to who she is, she knows that if Ron doesn't like her for who she is then he's not worth the effort. Instead she waits for him to be emotionally ready and for him to realise that he loves her too. It's the same with Luna she does't compromise on who she is, she knows people think she's "odd" but her desire for friendship doesn't mean she's going to change who she is. She knows that real friends will love her exactly the way she is.