100's of reasons why HP is better than Twilight.
Nov 22, 2010 14:55:39 GMT -8
Post by Time Lord on Nov 22, 2010 14:55:39 GMT -8
Who remembers this from the old board?
I thought it was more fitting to make the number more than just 100.
1. Harry Potter has a plot.
2. Harry Potter is an in depth story which captures the readers interest while Twilight is boring and predictable.
3. Harry Potter contains characters with personality.
4. Though Harry Potter is about wizards, the characters are easy to relate to with actual flaws.
5. J.K. Rowling isn't being sued for plagiarism.
6. Harry Potter isn't read simply for the hot guys.
7. Harry Potter contains small details in the beginning of the series which become important later in the story.
8. Many of the major plot holes in Harry Potter are cleared up by the end of the 7th book. In Twilight, I was just left with more questions.
9. J.K. Rowling sticks to her own canon.
10. Harry Potter was a well thought out story from the very beginning which made it easier to tie everything up neatly in the end. Twilight, as I've said before, just left me with more questions and a slightly queasy stomach.
11. Harry Potter remains completely consistent through the entire series.
12. Harry Potter can actually teach you valuable life lessons.
13. Harry Potter allows you to use your imagination to fill in the blanks, instead of repeatedly using different adjectives to describe the same object every few lines or so.
14. J.K. Rowling trusts her readers to think for themselves so they actually learn, as opposed to repeatedly bashing the reader over the head until their brain is mush and they are willing to take anything you hand them at face value.
15. J.K. Rowling uses words properly, as opposed to repeatedly abusing the thesaurus to mine for any "smart" sounding words available.
16. J.K. Rowling tends to research her fantasy series to make it as believable and plausible as possible.
17. J.K. Rowling created an entire world for her readers to get lost in, as opposed to throwing incredible (and I do mean INCREDIBLE) magical creatures into the real world.
18. J.K. Rowling built up the suspense of Voldemort and turned him into an actual threat instead of defeating him in seconds as Twilight does.
19. J.K. Rowling included fantastical creatures in her story that are far more realistic to me than a sparkly pixie.
20. Harry Potter is filled with actual conflict between characters but Harry doesn’t spend 1,800 pages of a 2,200 page series whining about them! He actually does something about it!
21. Harry Potter broke up with Ginny Weasley and neither one of them spent 6 full months in a comatose state or attempted suicide.
22. Harry Potter is full of hidden details which you can only catch by rereading the series, whereas Twilight was so bland I don’t care enough to know whether I missed anything.
23. Harry Potter is about a boy wizard with a lightning bolt scar on his forehead brandishing a stick, and I find it far more believable than a “vegetarian” vampire that sparkles in the sunlight.
24. When J.K. Rowling writes frightening characters or mythical creatures in her stories, THEY ARE ACTUALLY FRIGHTENING!
25. If J.K. Rowling wrote that baboons were actually wizards in hiding, I would probably believe it.
26. Harry Potter keeps you on the edge of your seat.
27. J.K. Rowling’s editor actually does their job.
28. When J.K. Rowling writes the back-story of one of her characters she does far more than bring it up once and forget about it; she actually spends a large portion of the 6th book explaining the origins of Lord Voldemort.
29. J.K. Rowling doesn’t bludgeon the myth in question to bits; she will take an idea, improve on it and smooth out the edges until she has morphed it into something pretty damn amazing.
30. Smeyer completely destroys any and all rules that were previously established (and not in a good way) by far better authors.
31. J.K. Rowling began Harry Potter as a children’s series but adapted her writing style to accommodate her audiences increasing age.
32. Harry Potter has actual character development.
33. J.K. Rowling created the perfect characters for her story rather than just creating “perfect” characters for any story.
34. Renesme Cullen? Ha! Albus Percival Wulfric Bryan Dumbledore laughs in his grave.
35. Harry Potter is a modest person who is completely happy with Ron and Hermione as his friends. He is also entirely uncomfortable with being famous and the attention he gets because of it.
36. Harry Potter breaks up with Cho Chang and his life goes on; we don’t get 6 blank pages while he wallows in self pity.
37. Harry Potter hates people for good reason, and because of this, we can’t help but hate them as well.
38. Harry Potter may become attracted to someone because of their looks, but he doesn’t try to use that as the
basis for a long successful relationship.
39. Even Dumbledore admits he isn’t perfect.
40. Harry Potter isn’t completely preoccupied with porking everything in sight.
41. Harry Potter is filled with complex relationships based on longstanding friendships instead of immediate sexual attraction.
42. J.K. Rowling uses effective foreshadowing instead of throwing the entire plot into the reader’s face in one fell swoop.
43. Harry Potter began as a light-hearted tale and steadily got darker as Lord Voldemort got stronger.
44. Harry Potter began over a decade ago and people are still reading the books. (J.K. Rowling must’ve done something right.)
45. The statement “the words aren’t always perfect” has NEVER been applied to Harry Potter.
46. Even in Stephen King’s eyes J.K. Rowling is the superior author.
47. There is no such thing as harrypottersucks.com.
48. J.K. Rowling didn’t fully understand the vastness of the fandom behind Harry Potter until AFTER she had completed the 7th novel, whereas Smeyer actually tacked 3 extra novels onto Twilight because of the growing popularity.
49. Harry Potter is the product of years of J.K. Rowling’s blood, sweat, and tears while Twilight was just pulled out of someone’s bum on the fly.
50. Harry Potter is noble, heroic and often selfless. He is willing to risk his life for people he doesn’t know or even like. (Ex: Harry Potter saved Draco Malfoy in the Room of Requirement in the 7th book.)
51. Hermione Granger is a strong, talented and ambitious character which we can all be proud of (even when she messes up : constant fighting with Ronald, Failing 3rd year DaDA exam, allowing a Death Eater to grab onto her while apparating to Grimmauld Place).
52. J.K. Rowling uses plot devices effectively and believably while Smeyer doesn’t.
53. Harry Potter isn’t filled with jokes based on sexual innuendos.
54. Harry Potter allows the reader to develop deep personal connections with the characters.
55. Lily Potter loved her son so much, she died for him; the “love” shown between Bella Swan and Edward Cullen pales dramatically in comparison.
56. J.K. Rowling has no fear of killing off characters—even if she did cry whilst doing so.
57. Harry Potter is kind to even the most seemingly insignificant creatures. He dug the grave for Dobby by hand in tribute to the hard work Dobby devoted his life to doing.
58. Harry Potter remains loyal to his friends no matter how unpopular. Ex: in the 6th book on the train ride to Hogwarts, Romilda Vane comes and invites Harry to join her and her friends in their compartment saying he doesn’t have to sit with Neville and Luna. He refuses saying, “but they’re my friends.” Bella left her human friends behind the moment Edward Cullen gave her a second look.
59. Harry had to work hard to succeed, Bella Swan had everything handed to her.
60. Harry Potter characters have some sort of affect towards the plot. They aren’t just there for the sake of being there.
61. J.K. Rowling doesn’t try to explain things away with sciences and fail epically at it.
62. Characters in Harry Potter are willing to die for one another, and some have. The final battle is proof that many of the students at Hogwarts would die to save Harry.
63. Harry Potter is a story which I would have no qualms about reading to my children as a bedtime story. I wouldn’t let my children within 50 feet of Twilight, even with a blowtorch.
64. Harry Potter has enough content for a full length movie.
65. In all the years I’ve read Harry Potter, I have never had to close the book, put it down and walk away shaking my head the way I did in the sparkling scene of Twilight.
66. Harry Potter shows you that immortality can destroy you while Twilight claims that if you aren’t immortal you aren’t worth shit.
67. I have never once face-palmed while reading Harry Potter.
68. No one ever whined about the shitty weather, even if it meant that Dementors where breeding.
69. J.K. Rowling writes fight scenes with actual climaxes.
70. J.K. Rowling can find a less cliché way of ending a series than “and we walked into our perfect piece of forever” or whatever shit Smeyer wrote.
71. J.K. Rowling proved that some young adult books should be over 700 pages long, Smeyer proved that some shouldn’t be.
72. If J.K. Rowling were to ever write a fight scene in which one character kills another, the person whose point of view we’re reading in would not black out leaving us utterly clueless as to what’s going on.
73. Harry Potter would never try to pass off stalking, pedophilia, and abuse as “true love”.
74. Harry Potter keeps you guessing; the reader never truly knew where Severus Snape’s loyalties truly lied until one of the last chapters of the last book.
75. Many people say the Cullens are great because they are attractive and wealthy. Whenever someone brings this up, I say “The Weasleys”; they may not be rich or well dressed, but they have love. Honestly, what more could any person want? Mrs. Weasley actually murdered Bellatrix Lestrange because Bellatrix attacked her daughter, Ginny. The Weasleys are kind, loving and are happy to welcome you in as another member of the family.
Some of these I remembered from the other forum, and some I made up myself.
Feel free to add more if you want to.
I thought it was more fitting to make the number more than just 100.
1. Harry Potter has a plot.
2. Harry Potter is an in depth story which captures the readers interest while Twilight is boring and predictable.
3. Harry Potter contains characters with personality.
4. Though Harry Potter is about wizards, the characters are easy to relate to with actual flaws.
5. J.K. Rowling isn't being sued for plagiarism.
6. Harry Potter isn't read simply for the hot guys.
7. Harry Potter contains small details in the beginning of the series which become important later in the story.
8. Many of the major plot holes in Harry Potter are cleared up by the end of the 7th book. In Twilight, I was just left with more questions.
9. J.K. Rowling sticks to her own canon.
10. Harry Potter was a well thought out story from the very beginning which made it easier to tie everything up neatly in the end. Twilight, as I've said before, just left me with more questions and a slightly queasy stomach.
11. Harry Potter remains completely consistent through the entire series.
12. Harry Potter can actually teach you valuable life lessons.
13. Harry Potter allows you to use your imagination to fill in the blanks, instead of repeatedly using different adjectives to describe the same object every few lines or so.
14. J.K. Rowling trusts her readers to think for themselves so they actually learn, as opposed to repeatedly bashing the reader over the head until their brain is mush and they are willing to take anything you hand them at face value.
15. J.K. Rowling uses words properly, as opposed to repeatedly abusing the thesaurus to mine for any "smart" sounding words available.
16. J.K. Rowling tends to research her fantasy series to make it as believable and plausible as possible.
17. J.K. Rowling created an entire world for her readers to get lost in, as opposed to throwing incredible (and I do mean INCREDIBLE) magical creatures into the real world.
18. J.K. Rowling built up the suspense of Voldemort and turned him into an actual threat instead of defeating him in seconds as Twilight does.
19. J.K. Rowling included fantastical creatures in her story that are far more realistic to me than a sparkly pixie.
20. Harry Potter is filled with actual conflict between characters but Harry doesn’t spend 1,800 pages of a 2,200 page series whining about them! He actually does something about it!
21. Harry Potter broke up with Ginny Weasley and neither one of them spent 6 full months in a comatose state or attempted suicide.
22. Harry Potter is full of hidden details which you can only catch by rereading the series, whereas Twilight was so bland I don’t care enough to know whether I missed anything.
23. Harry Potter is about a boy wizard with a lightning bolt scar on his forehead brandishing a stick, and I find it far more believable than a “vegetarian” vampire that sparkles in the sunlight.
24. When J.K. Rowling writes frightening characters or mythical creatures in her stories, THEY ARE ACTUALLY FRIGHTENING!
25. If J.K. Rowling wrote that baboons were actually wizards in hiding, I would probably believe it.
26. Harry Potter keeps you on the edge of your seat.
27. J.K. Rowling’s editor actually does their job.
28. When J.K. Rowling writes the back-story of one of her characters she does far more than bring it up once and forget about it; she actually spends a large portion of the 6th book explaining the origins of Lord Voldemort.
29. J.K. Rowling doesn’t bludgeon the myth in question to bits; she will take an idea, improve on it and smooth out the edges until she has morphed it into something pretty damn amazing.
30. Smeyer completely destroys any and all rules that were previously established (and not in a good way) by far better authors.
31. J.K. Rowling began Harry Potter as a children’s series but adapted her writing style to accommodate her audiences increasing age.
32. Harry Potter has actual character development.
33. J.K. Rowling created the perfect characters for her story rather than just creating “perfect” characters for any story.
34. Renesme Cullen? Ha! Albus Percival Wulfric Bryan Dumbledore laughs in his grave.
35. Harry Potter is a modest person who is completely happy with Ron and Hermione as his friends. He is also entirely uncomfortable with being famous and the attention he gets because of it.
36. Harry Potter breaks up with Cho Chang and his life goes on; we don’t get 6 blank pages while he wallows in self pity.
37. Harry Potter hates people for good reason, and because of this, we can’t help but hate them as well.
38. Harry Potter may become attracted to someone because of their looks, but he doesn’t try to use that as the
basis for a long successful relationship.
39. Even Dumbledore admits he isn’t perfect.
40. Harry Potter isn’t completely preoccupied with porking everything in sight.
41. Harry Potter is filled with complex relationships based on longstanding friendships instead of immediate sexual attraction.
42. J.K. Rowling uses effective foreshadowing instead of throwing the entire plot into the reader’s face in one fell swoop.
43. Harry Potter began as a light-hearted tale and steadily got darker as Lord Voldemort got stronger.
44. Harry Potter began over a decade ago and people are still reading the books. (J.K. Rowling must’ve done something right.)
45. The statement “the words aren’t always perfect” has NEVER been applied to Harry Potter.
46. Even in Stephen King’s eyes J.K. Rowling is the superior author.
47. There is no such thing as harrypottersucks.com.
48. J.K. Rowling didn’t fully understand the vastness of the fandom behind Harry Potter until AFTER she had completed the 7th novel, whereas Smeyer actually tacked 3 extra novels onto Twilight because of the growing popularity.
49. Harry Potter is the product of years of J.K. Rowling’s blood, sweat, and tears while Twilight was just pulled out of someone’s bum on the fly.
50. Harry Potter is noble, heroic and often selfless. He is willing to risk his life for people he doesn’t know or even like. (Ex: Harry Potter saved Draco Malfoy in the Room of Requirement in the 7th book.)
51. Hermione Granger is a strong, talented and ambitious character which we can all be proud of (even when she messes up : constant fighting with Ronald, Failing 3rd year DaDA exam, allowing a Death Eater to grab onto her while apparating to Grimmauld Place).
52. J.K. Rowling uses plot devices effectively and believably while Smeyer doesn’t.
53. Harry Potter isn’t filled with jokes based on sexual innuendos.
54. Harry Potter allows the reader to develop deep personal connections with the characters.
55. Lily Potter loved her son so much, she died for him; the “love” shown between Bella Swan and Edward Cullen pales dramatically in comparison.
56. J.K. Rowling has no fear of killing off characters—even if she did cry whilst doing so.
57. Harry Potter is kind to even the most seemingly insignificant creatures. He dug the grave for Dobby by hand in tribute to the hard work Dobby devoted his life to doing.
58. Harry Potter remains loyal to his friends no matter how unpopular. Ex: in the 6th book on the train ride to Hogwarts, Romilda Vane comes and invites Harry to join her and her friends in their compartment saying he doesn’t have to sit with Neville and Luna. He refuses saying, “but they’re my friends.” Bella left her human friends behind the moment Edward Cullen gave her a second look.
59. Harry had to work hard to succeed, Bella Swan had everything handed to her.
60. Harry Potter characters have some sort of affect towards the plot. They aren’t just there for the sake of being there.
61. J.K. Rowling doesn’t try to explain things away with sciences and fail epically at it.
62. Characters in Harry Potter are willing to die for one another, and some have. The final battle is proof that many of the students at Hogwarts would die to save Harry.
63. Harry Potter is a story which I would have no qualms about reading to my children as a bedtime story. I wouldn’t let my children within 50 feet of Twilight, even with a blowtorch.
64. Harry Potter has enough content for a full length movie.
65. In all the years I’ve read Harry Potter, I have never had to close the book, put it down and walk away shaking my head the way I did in the sparkling scene of Twilight.
66. Harry Potter shows you that immortality can destroy you while Twilight claims that if you aren’t immortal you aren’t worth shit.
67. I have never once face-palmed while reading Harry Potter.
68. No one ever whined about the shitty weather, even if it meant that Dementors where breeding.
69. J.K. Rowling writes fight scenes with actual climaxes.
70. J.K. Rowling can find a less cliché way of ending a series than “and we walked into our perfect piece of forever” or whatever shit Smeyer wrote.
71. J.K. Rowling proved that some young adult books should be over 700 pages long, Smeyer proved that some shouldn’t be.
72. If J.K. Rowling were to ever write a fight scene in which one character kills another, the person whose point of view we’re reading in would not black out leaving us utterly clueless as to what’s going on.
73. Harry Potter would never try to pass off stalking, pedophilia, and abuse as “true love”.
74. Harry Potter keeps you guessing; the reader never truly knew where Severus Snape’s loyalties truly lied until one of the last chapters of the last book.
75. Many people say the Cullens are great because they are attractive and wealthy. Whenever someone brings this up, I say “The Weasleys”; they may not be rich or well dressed, but they have love. Honestly, what more could any person want? Mrs. Weasley actually murdered Bellatrix Lestrange because Bellatrix attacked her daughter, Ginny. The Weasleys are kind, loving and are happy to welcome you in as another member of the family.
Some of these I remembered from the other forum, and some I made up myself.
Feel free to add more if you want to.